Anxiety! The Musical

Yeah lol this take is weird for a few reasons. First of all if you don’t mind the ship idk why you care about what is a “good” reason to ship them. Characters can and have been shipped together because they looked at each other once and for no reason at all, and that’s perfectly fine because like, who cares?

Second, I am so tired of people blaming Zuko for Azula shooting lightning at Katara. Zuko wasn’t goading Azula out of stupidity or pride, he was trying to end the fight quickly without involving anyone else using a move he knew Azula had no defense against that he had used once before against his father, to quickly end a fight without violence. He did not think Azula would go for Katara because that is against the rules - that Azula set, because she challenged Zuko - of an agni kai. You could MAYBE say that Zuko should have anticipated that Azula would cheat, but that’s always been their dynamic. Zuko is always too honorable and Azula is always lying and cheating. What has changed is that she’s no longer able to manipulate Zuko and is revealed to be the lying cheater that she always was, but that still doesn’t mean he could have anticipated her aiming at Katara, who had to be exactly in the right place at the right time.

As far as him “doing the bare minimum”…I mean, I do think he would have done it regardless of who it was who was in danger and his relationship to them, but that’s not a reason to diminish what he did, either. It takes incredible fortitude to put yourself in harm’s way for another person, and fast reflexes to get there in time. Katara herself is frozen to the spot, which is a natural reaction to danger, but if Zuko had done that or not reacted fast enough or even been slightly off, she or he would have died instantly. So let’s not belittle what Zuko did in sacrificing his own life to save someone else in an incredible act of selflessness, compassion, and heroism just because we don’t like a ship.

Third, these takes always miss WHY it’s seen as a shippy moment. It’s not only the culmination of a specific narrative arc between the three of them, the thematic motif of Zuko being positioned between what Azula and Katara represent to him, respectively, the choice between selfishness and selflessness, hate and love, cruelty and forgiveness - which alone are pretty damn good reasons to ship them. But not only that, it’s the strong emotions that are created from that act. I don’t think Zuko jumped in front of the lightning because he loved her. But you can’t help but love someone after that, after giving your whole being to another person in that moment. And Katara does the same thing for Zuko. Sure, you could argue that she would have done it anyway, her morals wouldn’t allow her to let him die, but the act itself still remains, with all its meaning, and the emotion behind it.

And the narrative goes out of its way to tell us that this is impossible! That a failure to redirect lightning correctly will result in perma-death. That Katara’s powers of healing alone weren’t enough to bring someone back from that precipice without spirit water. But they do it anyway. They save each other, through sheer force of will, and they can’t not be tied to each other after that.

If that’s not a good enough reason to ship, I don’t know what is. Which doesn’t mean you have to, of course. You are free to not vibe with a ship, regardless of the reasoning behind it. But don’t tell me it’s not a damned good reason.